Illegal search leads to dismissal of evidence in Fall River drug case
Illegal search and seizure in Massachusetts will prevent drugs and a gun from being used against a Fall River man facing federal criminal charges in U.S. District Court, the Herald News reported.
Chief Judge Mark Wolf ruled in favor of the defense in excluding part of the evidence Fall River vice detectives uncovered during a search of the Blackstreet Home of defendant Aryam Gonzalez during a raid on Feb. 13, 2009. A second motion is pending before the court that asks the judge to prevent prosecutors from introducing at trial a second gun allegedly found in the home.
This case illustrates the dramatic impact an experienced Fall River defense lawyer can have on a case when successfully arguing that law enforcement inappropriately searched a defendant's car, home or person. Evidence found as the result of a search is frequently the primary reason for bringing charges. A reduction or dismissal of the charges often results when such evidence is then excluded from court.
During a suppression hearing in May, evidence was presented that vice detectives were executing a search warrant on the defendant's home when he walked out and began to run away. He was tackled, placed in a choke hold and punched during arrest after officers claim he attempted to conceal drugs in his mouth. During the arrest, he allegedly told police where to find drugs and a gun in a shoebox in his room.
The judge ruled Gonzalez did not knowingly waive his right to remain silent while make a statement during such a physical arrest. Therefore, prosecutors will not be able to use that evidence in court. A second gun was found beneath the defendant's mattress.
Gonzalez has remained in custody while awaiting trial. He faces up to 15 years in prison if convicted. However, unless successfully appealed, the judge's ruling will likely result in a reduction or dismissal of a substantial part of the case against him.
Continue reading "Illegal search leads to dismissal of evidence in Fall River drug case " »